| AutoAwards Earnings Program | Basic | Gold | Platinum |
| Earn Points On Qualified Purchases | 15% of Every Dollar Spent | 15% of Every Dollar Spent | 15% of Every Dollar Spent |
| Customer Appreciation Bonus | $25 in Points | $25 in Points | $125 in Points |
| First Swipe Bonus | $50 in Points | $50 in Points | $50 in Points |
| Extended Service Contract Bonus | $150 in Points | $250 in Points | |
| Friends and Family Referral Bonus | $100 in Points | $150 in Points | $250 in Points |
| Your Future Vehicle Savings (New / Pre-Owned Purchases) | Up to $1,500 in Points | Up to $2,250 in Points | Up to $3,000 in Points |
Service Supremacy | |||
| $14.95 Oil Changes* | 1 | Up to 10 | Up to 15 |
| VIP Shuttle Service | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Car Wash with Service | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| NYS Annual Inspection** | Up to 5 (your vehicle only) | Up to 5 (your vehicle only) | FREE for Entire Household |
| Tire Rotations | Up to 5 | Up to 10 | |
| Tire Balances | Up to 5 | ||
| Priority Service Scheduling | Yes | ||
| One White Glove Detail | Yes | ||
| Extended Service Contract Guarantee | 50% | 100% | |
| New Wiper Replacement | Up to 5 | ||
Members-Only AutoAwards Benefits | |||
| Lost Key Return Service | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Valuable Everyday Merchant Discounts | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Matthews Travel Rewards Program | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Membership Fee | |||
| Non-Matthews Customer | $399 | $699 | $1,499 |
| Matthews Auto Customer | $0 (Waived) | $199 | $599 |