
Matthews Auto has been family owned since 1973 and we have an award-winning reputation. We're all about treating our Customers with the respect they deserve, that's why we are still offering fair, transparent prices. At Matthews you won't find mark-ups over MSRP, hidden charges, OR market rate adjustment fees.
Â
 With 15 franchises and 15 brands, we have an excellent selection of new, preowned and certified preowned vehicles to give you the best variety! We have multiple locations in the Southern Tier, Central NY, Western NY & Northern PA to better serve you. Every vehicle is priced with transparent prices to avoid hassles. We believe in long term relationships with our customers and feel that a respectful and enjoyable buying experience is crucial to meet this goal. Whether you're looking to Buy or Lease your next vehicle, we have great relationships with lenders to get you into the vehicle of your choice.Â
You and your safety are our top priority and we maintain a clean and sanitized environment for all and encourage appointments to meet with our staff. Schedule your sales or service appointment on our site or within the Matthews App. You can also buy completely online with Matthews Direct.
Get rewarded with our exclusive loyalty program Matthews Rewards Plus, and receive member-only benefits like exclusive Service Benefits, VIP Shuttle Service, Free Car Washes & more.
Our experienced sales staff works on a flat commission, so their main priority is to help you find the best vehicle for your needs- not the most expensive! Plus, we'll buy your car even if you don't buy from us!
Click on one of our locations below to find us. We look forward to serving you soon!

Contact
Vestal Dealership Hours
- Monday 9:00AM-6:00PM
- Tuesday 9:00AM-6:00PM
- Wednesday 9:00AM-6:00PM
- Thursday 9:00AM-6:00PM
- Friday 9:00AM-6:00PM
- Saturday 9:00AM-4:00PM
- Sunday Closed